yogiraj shrikrishn -lala lajapataray
7. puranoan ki prachinata
prophesar vilsan[1] ka mat hai ki vishnupuran mean is bat ke bahutere praman maujood haian ki usamean dasavian shatabdi eesvi tak ke vrittant paye jate haian. tathapi bhagavat tatha any puranoan ki apeksha vishnupuran adhik prachin hai. bhagavat ke vishay mean to yah vivad chala ata hai, ki kaun-si bhagavat atharah puranoan mean ginati karane yogy hai? shrimadbhagavat ya devi bhagavat? vaishnav apani bhagavat ko vastavik puran batalate haian aur shakt apani pustak ko. yooropiy vidvanoan ka mat hai ki shrimadbhagavat terahavian shatabdi eesvi mean likhi gee hai. jo kuchh vidvanoan ki drishti mean bhagavat se vishnupuran adhik prachin hai, tatha usamean alankar ka mishran bhi kam hone se usaki batean adhik vishvasaniy mani jati haian. isake atirikt auroan ki apeksha vishnupuran is yogy hai ki ghatanaoan ke anusandhan ki nianv usi par rakhi jaye. rachana-kal ki drishti se harivansh, brahmavaivart aur brahmapuran bhi vishnupuran se pashchat ke mane jate haian. prophesar vilsan ki sammati hai ki brahmavaivart gokulie gosaiyoan ki rachana hai aur 15vian shatabdi eesvi se pichhe ki likhi huee hai. ab raha mahabharat, so usake vishay mean yad rakhana chahie ki vartaman mahabharat asali mahabharat nahian hai. ya yoan kaho ki koee yah nahian bata sakata ki vartaman mahabharat mean kitane shlok asali haian aur kitane prakshipt arthat bad mean milaye ge haian. jaise puranoan ke vishay mean sadharanatah yah kaha jata hai ki ve vedavyas ji ke banae hue haian vaise hi mahabharat ke vishay mean bhi yahi kaha jata hai. parantu jaisa ham oopar kah aye haian ki kam-se-kam vartaman puran vyas ke rache hue nahian haian vaise hi hamare pas is bat ke bhi bahut-se praman haian ki adhunik mahabharat ka kul aansh vyas ji ka likha hua nahian hai. svayan mahabharat ke adiparv se pratit hota hai ki vyas ji ne asal mahabharat rachakar vaishampayan ko sunaya, jisane lomaharshan ko usaki shiksha di aur jisase usake putr ugrashrava ne use sikha. adhunik mahabharat ke pahale do shlokoan mean granthakarta[2] likhata hai ki vah us mahabharat ko likhata hai jo ugrashrava ne kulapati shaunak ke yajn[3] mean rrishiyoan ke sammukh sunaee thi. |
tika tippani aur sandarbh
- ↑ jinhoanne vishnupuran ka aangreji anuvad kiya hai.
- ↑ jo apana nam nahian prakat karata.
- ↑ barah varsh ke yajn
sanbandhit lekh
adhyay | adhyay ka nam | prishth sankhya |
varnamala kramanusar lekh khoj